Skip to main content

Should Zimbabwe consider a universal basic income scheme?

The IMF is supporting the Government of Zimbabwe as it carries out painful reforms, which will see a contraction of the wage bill, a reduction in agricultural input subsidies, rationalization of support to loss-making parastatals/state-owned enterprises (SOEs) among other priorities. These reforms are needed – Zimbabwe spends more on civil servant emoluments (82 percent of revenue) than the average Sub-Saharan African country (49.5 percent of revenue). SOEs have, in the past, engaged in the practice of acquiring companies that have non-performing loans in their balance sheets – effectively transferring debts onto public accounts, worsening Zimbabwe’s fiscal position.

While the Zimbabwean authorities are working to get the fiscal affairs in order there is need for substantial donor support for social protection. This includes programming meant to ease the cost of living for the poor and to provide a safety net when households and individuals fall into hard times, as indeed they will as fiscal cuts take effect. The international community should be working with the government to introduce a Universal Basic Income (UBI), funded by donors. This UBI should primarily be targeted at urban dwellers as existing social protection schemes (a school feeding program, a cash transfer scheme, a primary and secondary school education subsidy program among others) are largely aimed at rural households. In the May 2019 Staff Report by the IMF, the government has promised to maintain the floor of social spending. But effort is needed to better target this spending.

UBI experiments are ongoing in other parts of the world. In Kenya, researchers at Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) have partnered with GiveDirectly to evaluate the effects of universal basic income on a wide range of economic and social outcomes.

In March 2016, the government of Ontario, Canada introduced a three-year pilot basic income program. 4,000 people were provided with monthly benefits to lift them to at least 75 percent of the poverty line (Bergstein 2018). Following a tax credit model, the Ontario basic income pilot ensured that participants received up to $16,989 per year for a single person, less 50 percent of any earned income; $24,027 per year for a couple, less 50 percent of any earned income. People with a disability received up to $500 per month on top. The Ontario experiment began to be wound down from March 2019.

UBI, an idea whose time has come (again), should be pursued as a social protection strategy for Zimbabwe. There is at present a confluence of events that make it opportune to do so. Zimbabwe’s mobile payments system (Eco-cash) allows for direct distribution of universal cash transfers to millions. The advent of platforms like GiveDirectly in Kenya, which make use of M-PESA to send cash transfers to individuals means there is precedence for such an approach in Zimbabwe. The protracted pain that Zimbabweans are yet to endure requires bold action to ensure that the much needed macro-fiscal SMP program succeeds.

[1] IMF (2001). Country Report No, 01/05

Comments

Post a Comment

Constructive feedback is always welcome. Thank you

Popular posts from this blog

Malaysia at a Cross Roads: Diagnosing the Constraints to High Income Status

Malaysia at a Crossroads: Diagnosing Constraints to High-Income Status In 2008, Malaysia was recognized by the Growth Commission – a distinguished panel comprising 2 Nobel Prize Winning Economists and other leading development practitioners – as one of thirteen countries that sustained high growth in the post-war period. The 30-year stretch that caught the attention of the Growth Commission was between 1967 and 1997 when Malaysia grew at an average of 7.3% per year. This long stretch of growth was interrupted by periods of external shocks including the Volcker shock of 1986, the Asian Financial crisis in 1997/8, later the so-called Dot Com Bubble of 2001, and more recently the Global Financial Crisis of 2008. Despite these shocks, Malaysia remained resilient - formally earning the title "Upper Middle Income Country" in 1992. (See summary figure that breaks down the country's per capita growth story). As...
2 comments
Read more

Corporate Network Analysis

The complex interconnections that define modern society are most readily visible from our Facebook, Twitter, or Linkedin networks. What is perhaps less talked about is the extent to which corporations are linked. I just started building a network of cross shareholding among Malaysia's corporations using listed company data. The map below is a preliminary visualization of the country's corporate network as of 2015. I use social network analysis (SNA) tools to partition or color the network into key connected components or communities therein. I have deliberately excluded company names but I will tell you that the biggest nodes represent the most connected shareholders including governments, fund managers, and international asset managers.  Malaysia's Corporate Network in 2015 Created Using Gephi 0.9.1 As the Malaysia economy has grown so has the complexity of the corporate network from few shareholders to many interlinked players. Below is a visualization using sha...
2 comments
Read more

Assessing labor market transitions in Ghana using panel data

Understanding labor market transitions is important for policymakers and researchers in developing countries. Changes in economic activity status (employed, unemployed, out of labor force) vary significantly from one country to another and also within countries from one socio-economic group to another. Below I summarize analysis from the latest Ghana Annual Household Income and Expenditure Survey ( AHIES ) published by the Ghana Statistical Service. The AHIES is a panel survey that has followed over 10,000 individuals since 2022Q1 to assess changes in their livelihoods. I am currently analyzing trends and show here what has happened to economic activity between Q2 and Q3.  Transitions in Ghana labor force status, 2022Q2 - 2022Q3 Source : Own analysis using AHIES from Ghana Statistical Service. Note : Left hand side is 2022Q2 and right side is 2022Q3 81 percent of working age individuals (15-64-years) who were  employed  in 2022Q2 were still employed in 2022Q3; 7 perc...
Post a Comment
Read more