The complex interconnections that define modern society are readily visible in our Facebook or LinkedIn networks. But what about the corporate world?
I recently began mapping the web of cross-shareholding among Malaysia's listed corporations. Using Social Network Analysis (SNA), I visualized the ecosystem to identify key "communities" and power brokers. The goal? To see if a company's position in this web predicts its financial destiny.
I recently began mapping the web of cross-shareholding among Malaysia's listed corporations. Using Social Network Analysis (SNA), I visualized the ecosystem to identify key "communities" and power brokers. The goal? To see if a company's position in this web predicts its financial destiny.
The map above visualizes the network as of 2015. While I have excluded specific company names, the "super-nodes" (the largest circles) represent the most connected shareholders in the economy—primarily government-linked investment companies (GLICs), fund managers, and international asset managers.
A Decade of Growing Complexity
As the Malaysian economy has grown, so has the complexity of its corporate ecosystem. Compare the dense web of 2015 (above) with the visualization below, based on data from 2005.
Figure 2: The sparsely connected network of 2005
Resilience vs. Returns
The evolution from "islands" of ownership to a massive "continent" of connectivity raises two critical questions:- Contagion Risk: Does this hyper-connectivity make Corporate Malaysia more vulnerable to shocks? If one central node fails, does the whole network shake?
- Performance: Does location matter? My preliminary analysis suggests that densely connected firms tend to have superior financial performance (higher profitability and ROE) compared to those on the periphery.
So much has changed in a decade. Good or bad?
ReplyDeleteThat is the purpose of the study. Its too early to say but the working hypothesis is that it depends. If greater connectedness has increased the risk of crisis contagion, then a dense network might not be ideal. If, however, it's led to more profitable and well-resourced companies, then it might be a good strategy for funds and other investors to allocate resources towards the most connected firms.
DeleteI will be posting follow-up material as the analysis progresses.